The Psychology of Finance, 1ère ou 2nde version ?

J'ai prévu de lire The Psychology of Finance de Tvede. En général j'achète les versions les plus récentes des bouquins, mais un commentaire assez tranché me fait hésiter :

Steven Phillips
4,0 sur 5 étoilesMake sure you get the first edition!
14 juin 2004 - Publié sur Amazon.com
Achat vérifié
Tvede presents a good, intermediate-level overview of market trading from a trend-following perspective. He also describes several indicators which are useful in assessing the "temperature" of the trading environment. However, aside from the clarity of his writing and the logical development of his argument, he offers little which is new to the experienced market practotooner.
Also, please note that this book was published in two editions. The first edition successfully views the mechanics of trading through the emotional filters which affect our buy-sell decisions. The second edition is a complete rewrite which morphs the book into a nebulous psychology text that is only occasionally related to the trading process. You would be well-served to avoid this second edition! First edition - 4 stars; second edition - 1 star.

Je suis preneur de vos avis, si vous avez lu une des versions, voire les deux.

Les deux, il y a des choses différentes mais intéressantes dans les deux. C'est juste une bonne vulgarisation de ce que l'on peut trouver partout ailleurs de toute façon.

Plutôt cryptique ton post xxxx

Tu parles de Tvede, du commentateur, de x, de moi, ou de toi à la 3è personne ?

edit : suite à ton edit, on parle de Tvede